It’s
interesting reading this excerpt right after reading The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn because that novel dealt with
the issue of slavery and the relations between white and blacks—blacks being
less equal than whites. Booker T.
Washington was asked to make a speech and in his speech he mentions the
tensions between blacks and whites. He
begins his speech with an story about dropping one’s bucket down to others—whites
need to drop their buckets to blacks.
Washington was trying to challenge their old convictions about blacks
not being their equal brethren. Each
race needs to realize that neither blacks nor whites are superior to either
one. Washington states, “nor should we
permit our grievances to overshadow our opportunities.” If they allow their old tensions to outweigh
new experiences, then they will never experience life at its fullest.
Washington continues by speaking about how blacks need to
drop their buckets to other blacks. They
must encourage one another; just like we as Americans must also. In America today we often talk about being
proud of our heritage and our freedom as a people. While we can or cannot be at times friendly
to those who come from other countries we also must stand strong next to our
culture and our people. For example,
instead of assuming the worst in someone instead assume the best of them and
the worst in the situation. We need to
give more credit to people rather than looking at them from negative lenses.
During his speech Washington has one key idea that has
been his platform which is “which blacks and whites can stand with full justice
to each other.” Now, for this time or
for the present the aspect of justice can be very subjective—especially for an
individual. Most people believe that
they, in fact, are right—they are morally making the right choices. This makes it considerable more complicated
and more difficult to find the real meaning and true justice.
I agree with you that it was very interesting reading Washington's excerpt from "Up From Slavery" right after reading Huckleberry Finn. Washington's piece was written only about 25 years after Twain began Huckleberry Finn and it is disheartening to see that not much change towards equality was made during the those years. I really liked what you had to say about justice being subjective and how, although we need to work together obtain it, not everyone is going to be seeking the same justice. This does make it hard to come to an agreement and push for change.
ReplyDeleteI loved that you took time to explore how Washington's exhortations can be applied to us today. This is the true treasure of literature, when it applicable and relevant to us. Yet, to make it relevant, since we don't have the exact racial equality issue, we must remove the situational details and find the major themes. I thought you did that quite well when discussing the need to assume the best in someone as opposed to our natural reaction to take them at their worst. Nicely written.
ReplyDelete